what makes the difference?

topic posted Thu, February 28, 2008 - 5:00 PM by  §t®ngV◊i©e
I think alot about what makes some people come from hard hard places and end up just amazing people and I can see how where they came from has made them the amazing person they are...and about people who seem to be hardened or broken or turned into someone who has no concern for others by their background. and what is the thing that makes that huge difference?
  • Re: what makes the difference?

    Thu, February 28, 2008 - 7:39 PM
    You know, that's an EXCELLENT question that psychologists have been trying to answer forever. Some of it actually seems to be genetic in nature. The Diathesis Stress model provides some insight into the extreme ends of such phenomena in relation to actual mental disorder. The way it was described to me is imagine that everybody has a cup and the stresses in their life fill up that cup and when that cup spills over they will have reached their breaking point and start exhibiting mental disorders, but genetics determines how big your cup is. There has to be an interaction between environment and genetics in order for disorder to exhibit.
    If you have some time take a gander at this, it'll change the way you think about genetics: video.stumbleupon.com/#p=trjny62bq0

    A also think there are little environmental factors that make a HUGE difference, especially in combination. Such things are impossible to track scientifically, one gets weighted down in the infinite minutia of a living creature and its interactions. Something as simple as getting some excellent advice from a grandfather that stuck, having one good friend that you trust to always be there for you no matter what else is happening, or having a firm belief in a benevolent God can all be very powerful things. Then there are crux moments when a person is in crisis and whatever they experience in that time seems to make the difference in which way they tip. There is the complicated workings of a persons autonomic nervous system and how well your body can handle physical stress and it's branches your sympathetic and parasympathetic nervous systems which determine how easily you fall into flight or fight mode and how easily you recover from it. There is just so MUCH. So many factors! We focus on the great traumas and often forget all the little things along the way that made just as much of a difference.


    But in the end the answer is, "We don't know."
    • Re: what makes the difference?

      Fri, February 29, 2008 - 1:40 PM
      Hmm I don't think I can go with the cup analogy...not completely because I think the stresses are what makes some people amazing as opposed to just regular healthy people. So the cup analogy seems like only half of the situation to me. Like definately people have different sizes of cups...but then there also must be something else about how people process the stuff that ends up in their cup.

      I agree that little or seemingly little things can make a huge different.

      one good friend definately. the god thing I think can push you either way. Some people process faith in god as some sort of scary thing that makes them sure they are horrible people...and some people process it as faith that things will turn out ok and that that line from I Am Queen comes to mind "my creator didn't make no mistakes on me." so I put that one in the powerful tool catagory...like a gun powerful but could be used for good or evil. If you believe in good and evil of course.

      So I wonder...what is your instinct of what personality characteristics are key to someone processing stress in a way that makes them stronger and more empathetic? (of course stronger and more empathetic is my idea of taking the bad and making good).

      So far the one that keeps coming back is a sense of personal responsiblity. Not buying into either it is everyone else's fault, or buying into I'm helpless and I can't do anything. But that inate(or is it inate?) sense that you have choices and are responsible for them. and that where ever you came from at some point you take over the sails and stear with the wind that comes along.
      • Re: what makes the difference?

        Fri, February 29, 2008 - 2:12 PM
        Thought: does stress truly make some people amazing or do amazing people shine in a crisis?

        Yes, religion can be terribly harmful for some people. That is part of why I specified a "benevolent" god. Most folks who actually believe in a god or pantheon that is truly benevolent tend to have a happier outlook on life. However, if their faith is broken it can absolutely ruin them. No judgments about religions or faiths or lack thereof, just an observation.

        I believe that a capability for critical but neutral self analysis is one component. Another, I think, is internalized motivation. A third is a strong ego and solid but flexible self identity. Yet another is a willingness to change opinions, habits, and perspectives and a tendency to look at things from multiple points of view. Ah, and optimism. Believing the world and its inhabitants are basically good goes a long way. A sense of purpose is also highly beneficial.
        Responsibility can go either way. My sense of personal responsibility actually makes me neurotic. It's over developed. I am hyper-sensitive to responsibility and because I take it SO seriously I desperately seek to avoid as much of it as I can because what I have just by being HUMAN is overwhelming! I believe a lot of that was learned, but I had to have a willingness to accept that teaching. There are also some folks who weather AMAZING trauma by completely abdicating their responsibility to a god, and organization, fate, or some other symbolic authority. They reject responsibility but still simply have a strong desire to give kindness and assistance.
        It's complicated. Any one trait alone is not enough. They have to support each-other.
        • Re: what makes the difference?

          Fri, February 29, 2008 - 2:30 PM
          you are making my head hurt(o:

          I have seen people who thought god was benevolent...but were sure they were disappointing this amazing god with their unworthyness.

          I can totally go with a critical but fairly neutral self analysis component. Yes that seems key to me.

          hmm I hadn't thought of responsility going that direction but now that I think about it I can see that. So it needs to be a healthy sense of responsiblity. Not missing or over sensitive.

          I will have to think about complete abdicating of responsibitlity and kindness. So far it's sounding like a concept I've never witness or concieved of...but I am willing to totally own that I have a bias against complete abdication of responsility, and connect it to god stuff and I'll have to work hard to see things objectively.

          I definately agree that no one trait is enough. I am just thinking that some traits might be necessary, even if they are not enough on their own.
        • Re: what makes the difference?

          Sat, March 1, 2008 - 12:49 PM
          "Believing the world and its inhabitants are basically good goes a long way."

          There was a time when I think we could have this way of thinking but I don't honestly believe that is possible in these days and times. I don't think I'm alone in this feeling either. Too many "bad" people out there who, when given even the slightest chance, will take advantage of the wide-eyed, "there's good in everyone" believers out there (aka, naive). It has become such a dog eat dog world even from my childhood years to now...I'm 52.
          • Re: what makes the difference?

            Sat, March 1, 2008 - 4:51 PM
            Woah, back it up. There's a HUGE difference between believing people are basically good and being naive and gullible enough. Being basically good does not prevent people from doing horrible things sometimes.
            I've never met a truly "bad" person in my life. I've met some really angry people, some scared people, some selfish people, some jaded people, some not-so-bright people, some too-smart-for-their-own-good people, and some confused people, but I've never met a BAD person. Most people have reasons for what they do though, and they truly believe their actions are justified. I believe to be truly "bad" or "evil" there must be intent. Accidents are accidents, which does not make the ACTIONS good but neither does it make the PERSON bad.
            • Re: what makes the difference?

              Sat, March 1, 2008 - 4:56 PM
              I have met truly bad people...then again I work in the mental health aspect of healthcare...and see the uglier side of human nature...unfortunately the bad seeds were not met in that atmosphere.
              • Re: what makes the difference?

                Sat, March 1, 2008 - 5:10 PM
                "then again I work in the mental health aspect of healthcare...and see the uglier side of human nature"

                Yeeeah, and? My degree's in psych. I've been in the wards and worked for the wards, and the mental/physical handicap hospitals, and the rehab clinics, and the hotlines, and the local jail. Still never met a bad person. Look, if you start thinking the folks coming into the mental health ward are "bad" people it might be time for you to take a burn-out vacation. Folks aren't stupid just because they're having some psych trouble; they can tell when you think of them that way and you're not doing them any favors by sticking around if that's your attitude.
                • Re: what makes the difference?

                  Sat, March 1, 2008 - 5:14 PM
                  Thank you Dr. Freud. I'm not a nurse on the unit. I work in the legal department...but I do see some who are nothing but trouble. I applaud your ability to see good in all...but I'm a cynic...have always been and always will be. Your rose-colored glasses will never fit my nose. Sorry.
                  • This is the maximum depth. Additional responses will not be threaded.

                    Re: what makes the difference?

                    Sat, March 1, 2008 - 6:24 PM
                    Freud would likely be as insulted by your comparison as I am.

                    Sigh. Again, there is a difference between wearing rose colored glasses and being able to see that even people who do horrible things have their good moments. I'm not untouched by misery and abuse and suffering and pain. Most folks would tell you I'm a cynic as well. People do stupid and awful and horrible things ALL the TIME. But they've all had their moments of being good too. They all have things they care about, ideals they uphold, ethics they stick to, and traits that are laudable. NONE of that prevents us from being absolutely shitty to each-other on a regular basis. None of it prevents me from seeing the horror and violence and cruelty and willful ignorance everywhere. I also won't let myself draw the "us and them" line of saying there are bad people and good people in the world. There aren't. There's just people.
                  • This is the maximum depth. Additional responses will not be threaded.

                    Re: what makes the difference?

                    Sun, March 2, 2008 - 10:59 AM
                    i have a feeling that working in the legal department might taint one's perceptions more than working in the wards.

                    as i said in my other post, jaded, it is the very belief that you are a cynic and can be nothing else that traps you in that way of seeing the world. nothing wrong with it if it makes you happy, but it doesn't look like it does. rose-colored glasses are no different than jade-colored glasses.... they don't change what happens around you, they just have you filter it in a certain way. changing glasses is entirely possible, and your experience of the world shifts. i've done it (and continue to do it on a daily basis) and i've seen it done by some of the most cynical burnouts ever.
    • Re: what makes the difference?

      Sat, March 1, 2008 - 12:44 PM
      Why do they assume that everyone has a cup? Every time I've been approached with that "is your cup half empty/half full" question, I reply, "What makes you think I have a cup?"
      • Re: what makes the difference?

        Sat, March 1, 2008 - 4:55 PM
        HA! Well, I don't think we're talking about the same cup but the reason they assume everybody has a cup is that it's very rare for a healthy person to pop out of the womb all insti-crazy. Usually there has to be a triggering event.
  • Re: what makes the difference?

    Fri, February 29, 2008 - 11:30 AM
    Perhaps, the "difference" is between who I am and what happens. As human beings, I think that we are the same: amazing. And, I have no idea what may happen in the next five seconds: oh shit!

    Yeah, I don't know.
    • how makes the difference?

      Sun, March 2, 2008 - 1:15 PM
      Perhaps, the question is not what, but how? We may judge what we are. We may also judge what we have done, and how we may have done it regardless of what. Do you see a difference? I think that how I respond is my response ability, and this may be the only choice I get to make.

      I desire to let go of my judgements, those stories my mind comes up with, and love us anyways.
      • Re:Love makes the difference?

        Sun, March 2, 2008 - 4:16 PM
        Great Question .......... Strong Voice....

        ****Hi**** ...waves..... (mmphosis, lelsie, myriad and jaded)

        I think it's love.... what we love......... we are passionate about........... how much love we pour into our communication of that passion .... We get to choose the volume and the level.............
        • Re:Love makes the difference?

          Mon, March 3, 2008 - 5:03 PM
          You're welcome(o:

          I think that I see being capable of loving as a sign that you are healthy in a way or area of yourself and life. So while I think that love is extremely important and doing things with love is a huge influence on if we live well and stay healthy I wonder what makes one person come out of an abusive home and be able to love and be loved? and what makes another unable to love and/or be loved?
  • Re: what makes the difference?

    Sun, March 2, 2008 - 10:50 AM
    i thnk it comes down to belief systems.

    someone who has a belief that it's possible to have challenges and still be happy comes through the hard places relatively unscathed, and someone who has a belief system that the world is a bad place, and that things aren't fair, is likely to turn out hardened and broken, jaded and cynical. in other words, it's about whether a person believes their circumstances define them or not.

    and the person who has also figured out that it is actually possible to choose another belief system, and therefore to shift what the outcome will be, is the one who emerges from what might seem to be the most impossible circumstances in the most amazing way.
    • Re: what makes the difference?

      Mon, March 3, 2008 - 4:59 PM
      I agree. But I think what I'm wondering is what makes one person capable of seeing that challanges come and you can still be happy and one person not be able to see that?
      • Re: what makes the difference?

        Mon, March 3, 2008 - 6:20 PM
        it's their belief system... and our beliefs come from many places, and often are made up of an amalgamation of what we were taught, what we experienced, what we've heard, what we know intuitively...

        we all have belief systems, and if we want to have power in our life, it's good to be able to examine them... for people whose beliefs bring them a sense of peace and happiness already, they might not be compelled to do that so much, but for those who believe things that bring them suffering (e.g. god is punishing, men are untrustworthy, i am ugly), then the freedom lies in being able to learn how to shift one's beliefs that aren't working for them.

        there are people who believe they cannot change, perhaps because their parents told them they'd always be an idiot, or their teacher told them that they cannot learn something, or because they were picked on as a kid and decided that there was something inherently wrong with them. and even those people, when they find themselves in a learning situation, perhaps the words of someone else, or a book, or just a personal epiphany, then they see that their belief was what was holding them back all along.

        i'm listening to echardt tolle right now in the live webcast class for oprah's book club, and his new book ' a new earth' -- this is how people learn and the awareness is spread that we are able to affect our experience of life by choosing our thoughts, and shifting our belief systems.
        • Re: what makes the difference?

          Mon, March 3, 2008 - 7:08 PM
          .. leslie ...
          as a kid and decided that there was something inherently wrong

          I think that's hitting the nail right on the head................ and the kid grew ......but the conversation did not .............
        • Re: what makes the difference?

          Tue, March 4, 2008 - 10:20 AM
          I think it's that amalgamation I'm thinking about. and wondering what element shows up in it to make some people Pollyanna (and I mean that in the wonderful way) and some people self defeatist.

          I can see how powerful what you believe is. I see that everywhere and everyday. I believe that part of the reason I'm so amazingly blessed is by the simple act of recognizing my blessings. Someone else could have the same life as me and be miserable and always be looking for what they don't have. But because I see the blessings I am happy. and because I see them more and more come.

          I just wonder how did I get the blessing of being able to see my blessings? (o: I know there is no answer for that, but I've been thinking about it and wondered what you all thought of it.
          • Re: what makes the difference?

            Tue, March 4, 2008 - 2:16 PM
            pollyanna-ish is, to me, as i think you know, **always** a wonderful thing.

            some of us just have a natural inclination to positivity, i think. when i was in the second grade, my teacher said i was delightful because i was the pollyanna of the class.

            and, natural inclination or not, it is entirely possible -- because i have seen it happen over and over -- for someone who filters things through negativity and powerlessness to have the ephiphany that they can indeed create happiness, because they were the ones responsible for creating their unhappiness. i went to a workshop once about the law of attraction, right after the secret movie and book came out, and there was a guy next to me who was the perfect example. he told me he'd been negative his entire life, he thought it was who he was and how it had to be... and then he read the secret, and started listening to the audio, and he realized that he'd had the power to shift that all along, simply by shifting his thoughts.

            in just a couple of months, he saved his marriage and totally transformed how he was experiencing life. he was so lit up, so glowing with the power he'd reclaimed, it was absolutely phenomenal.

            we see what we look for, we get what we think about. wherever someone is in a certain moment, when they get that's how it works, they have the ability to look for something better, to think about something positive.
            • Re: what makes the difference?

              Tue, March 4, 2008 - 4:01 PM
              Yes(o: I just wanted you to know I was agreeing with you about Pollyanna

              Yes I think that's true. I think some people do have a natural inclination to positivity. and I think you can wake up and change things.

              I remember when I was 18 the family that I was living with told me I was negative. I was shocked and horrified and did not believe I was negative. But I watched myself intensly and began to notice that I didn't say positive things out loud. I would think them, but I very rarely ever complimented anyone or spoke about the positive things I was thinking. But I would definately say the negative things. I didn't like that so I made a commitment to myself to say the positive. No matter how uncomfortable it was, no matter what. I would say the positive. and I began and from the random lady at the store who I said "cool skirt" too as I walked by to everyone in my life and to myself I began saying the positive things out loud. and it shifted me hugely. I don't remember when I began to believe that what you feed grows but I think that was a turning point in who I am that fed the even bigger things since then.

              I still held alot of anger and cynism and crap, it wasn't spilling out of me anymore it was deep down and focused at a few people and situations in my life. Until I fell in love with my then husband and was just so joyful to be where I was I had this realization that I would not be there if any of those things I'd resented had not happened, that I wouldn't be me or where I was and since I loved me and where I was those things had not cheated me out of the things I'd wanted but rather had brought me to what I had and that I wouldn't trade what I ended up with for the dreams I'd had.

              I guess I get stuck thinking about the why because deep in my heart I share a bit of MsMary's buttshine and I really do think people can change and be transformed...and when they don't or even more confounding they seem to go deeper into negativity I start to wonder if I'm being unfair. If maybe they really can't. Maybe I want to be able to give up because it's painful to have hope that someone will be the good person I see underneath while they seem to work so hard to be the lowest of what they could be.
              • Re: what makes the difference?

                Tue, March 4, 2008 - 4:37 PM
                ".and when they don't or even more confounding they seem to go deeper into negativity I start to wonder if I'm being unfair. "

                I think that's the balance between giving them the benefit of the doubt, but not actually expecting them to reach it... and then not getting too cynical to think automatically that they won't. ;) it's hard to have the positive outlook that people are essentially good, without also having the expectation that they *will* fulfill that. If your expectations are too low, then you can end up surrounding yourself with people who suck too much from you. If your expectations are too high, you'll be continually frustrated and disappointed with them.
            • Re: what makes the difference?

              Tue, March 4, 2008 - 7:53 PM
              Positive thinking can work wonders for sure. In my family, we have the natural tendency to think: "I you don't have anything to complain about, you're not paying close enough attention." Sad, but true! Despite being raised to be a nopey naysayer, I got shit done anyway. I have always had the natural inclination to achieve despite my level of happiness or outlook on the world.

              I changed my outlook when I decided I was tired of being a nopey, but my drive has always been there.

              To touch on your paragraphs about false modesty etc. I think that denying one's natural abilities for whatever reason is a crime against nature and yourself. Humility should never mean mediocrity, quite the opposite. It should open up our eyes to experience the wonders of one another and ourselves.
              • Re: what makes the difference?

                Thu, March 6, 2008 - 11:03 AM
                ok, I've been thinking about your post. and I think what I've come up with is that I wasn't equaling success with happiness or healthiness. Yes being healthy would mean being successful in certaint things...but I think you could have lots of drive and become very successful at lots of things and still not be happy (which to me is being successful at life, well maybe not happy as much as fullfilled/joyful).

                Yes having motivation is vital. But it's just part of what I was thinking about. Though an important peice. But a peice that can be there without the parts that heal us or help us become successful in life the way I'm thinking about. Maybe it's one of those things where all of the seeds have to be present. There must be a seed for motivation and a seed for seeing how our thoughts and actions create our environment and a seed for...

                hmm I need to think more.
  • Re: what makes the difference?

    Sun, March 2, 2008 - 10:21 PM
    I think the most concrete thing I can attribute it to is luck, and that's not very concrete.
    I may react more positively than another, I may have a different experience than they do, anything and everything is a variable and then there's the aspect of how we are hard-wired, as Myriad suggested. The specific combinations that produce the results can never really be explained conclusively.

    One might argue that it's belief systems, but I know people that interpret the same belief systems into allowing different behaviors depending on what they think the behavior means. We may have total control over what and who we are or none at all, most think it's somewhere in the middle. I guess that's why I go with luck. It also keeps me humble.
    • Re: what makes the difference?

      Mon, March 3, 2008 - 5:06 PM
      I'm curious why being humble is a good thing...or maybe what that means to you.
      • Re: what makes the difference?

        Mon, March 3, 2008 - 11:23 PM
        To me humility is simply realizing that I am no better or worse in value than anyone else. I am equal to everyone. We have different capabilities, talents, experiences and purposes and none of us truly know that of the others let alone our own half the time. How could I ever know the true value of any human being to put myself on a pedestal? Elevating myself in value presumes the right to assign value and that can lead to prejudices, even of the more abstract kind. Of course, we all do some of this all the time, albeit unconsciously or otherwise, but it's not a bad goal, I think, to realize that everyone is as valuable as ones self. We are all made with the stuff to have a rippled influence.
        • Re: what makes the difference?

          Tue, March 4, 2008 - 10:17 AM
          I believe that. I can even see that that is what humility is supposed to be. It seems that it's been used so much to keep people down. Don't believe you are better than anyone else...is said...but the message that went along with it was "because you are nothing special"

          for me I believe I am totally special and unique...just like everyone else(o: I think you see that too it's just that word hits me wrong.

          Is there a word that more expresses not we are all the same down here...and more we are all special wonderful magic in some way? Like I don't think I'm above anyone else...but I tend to think myself and everyone are higher than most people I think.
          • Re: what makes the difference?

            Tue, March 4, 2008 - 10:24 AM
            The word had been distorted in connotation. honestly, I don't even hear of the word and certainly not the concept anymore. I think our society has come to value self importance to the detriment of our communal relationships. I suppose that's the nature of a competitive economic system and the social impact it has. The sad news is we never stopped needing each other, we have just started denying it.

            The word that rubs me the wrong way is 'self-determination' in the context people use it today. I'm not even convinced there is such a thing ultimately. I really wonder why we need to feel self-determined? Why do we need to impose the concept of control onto anything? Doesn't it steal away the joy of just being somehow? Now, I'm all about choice, but I would have to see compelling evidence that proves we are totally in control of our lives but the definition of control would have to sorted out first.
            • Re: what makes the difference?

              Tue, March 4, 2008 - 10:32 AM
              growing up I heard it alot, and definately in connection with christianity and being humble before god. which icks me out.

              I will have to think about the self determination thing. I'm not sure I know what that means or how it's being used these days. Or what I think of the concept necessarily. I do struggle with the concept that I'm not in some kind of control of myself and my life. I can see that it causes me pain when I think I should be in control of more than I have any influence over. I'm still trying to find a balance though between choices and controling the sails even though I can't control the wind.
              • Re: what makes the difference?

                Tue, March 4, 2008 - 2:29 PM
                i don't have semantic connotations about the word 'humble' from my upbringing... though i do think that humility is a mark of a peaceful person, someone who isn't so tied up in their own personal ego and self-identity that they are unable to appreciate the wonderfulness of the other different kinds of people around them, someone who isn't driven to always have to be the focus of attention.

                i do, though, abhor false modesty, which is what i think is what a lot of people take on as if it is humility. i think false modesty is a dangerous thing... pretending not to hold a certain power or talent, playing down your own greatness in order not to shake other people up. this is how we create a world of the lowest common denominator, where everyone dresses, thinks and acts the same... and that kind of world is boring!

                i think if we would all be proud of what it is we're good at, be willing to acknowledge our gifts and superpowers, then the confidence and